Do Novels Need a Theme or Message to Have Value?

What is the purpose of a good book? Is it solely to provide entertainment, or should it entertain with a deeper purpose?

Can a book that doesn’t include any obvious messages or themes still be a good story? Does it have value, or is value based on displaying a certain truth or examining difficult questions?

Good and Bad Are Opinions

When it comes to reading books, everything is subjective. It’s not like plumbing, where there’s a clear right and wrong way to hook up the pipes. The value we assign to books is based on personal preferences, not on a guiding principle about what makes a book good or bad.

Some readers love a historical romance.

Others prefer a swashbuckling adventure or a stimulating science fiction tale.

Some want a story that weaves meaningful themes into the narrative, while others only care about the thrill of the story itself.

Does that make one inherently better than another?

Of course not.

Books That Entertain

Some books are nothing more than fun, adventurous stories without any apparent themes or messages hidden in the story.

That’s fine. Not every book needs to say something profound about life or offer a look at a challenging issue.

Some people might think these books lack value because they’re shallow or they don’t deal with important issues.

Not true. That’s like saying a tootsie roll isn’t food. It is, but we give it a different value than say a mouth-watering plate of turkey and mashed “po-tay-toes.”

We don’t expect candy to have the same benefits as a healthy meal, but that doesn’t discount your tootsie rolls. (There’s always a place for chocolate, right?)

Same with books.

Books That Entertain with a Deeper Purpose

If you dig deep enough, I think most books fall into this category. Even if it’s not obvious on the surface, they strive to reveal some deeper truth or tackle a specific topic.

  • Mercy and law contrasted (Les Miserables)
  • The consequences of man trying to play God (Jurassic Park)
  • The meaning of true love (Princess Bride)

Returning to the candy and food analogy, books that merely entertain us are like those tootsie rolls—enjoyable while they last, but fleeting and lacking any long-term benefit.

Books that weave a compelling theme into an exciting story are like a slice of filet mignon—delicious and nourishing at the same time. Those are the books we enjoy in the moment but that stay with us long after we’ve read the last page.

I’m not discounting the “candy” books, but the “steak” books are the ones truly worth reading.

Are Those Books Preachy?

Sometimes, people think that when a book deals with a specific topic in a pointed way, it becomes preachy. Nay-nay, I say. Look at these famous examples:

1. The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe

On the surface, this is a fun children’s fantasy story. Talking animals, a world found inside a wardrobe, a quest to save the enchanted world from the evil witch.

That’s all great, but the story doesn’t stop there. It goes much deeper, dealing with themes of love, redemption, and sacrifice.

2. The Hunger Games

This wildly popular series is one of the best examples of combining a gripping story with profound themes. The stories revolve around the Games, the rebellion of the districts, and the love triangle among Katniss, Peeta, and Gale.

But beneath the action, the themes flow like a strong undercurrent, refusing to be ignored. What are the effects of violence? What are the consequences of tyrannical rule?

Would you call those preachy? I don’t think so. If a book stresses a key theme in an overbearing way, instead of in a way that naturally flows from the story, that’s preaching—and a recipe for irritated readers.

But a strong message doesn’t make a book preachy by default.

All Books Have Value

In this case, beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Everyone has different tastes, and that’s fine. Personally, I think all books have value to some extent, but the ones that probe the deep questions have more meat on the bone, so to speak.

An exciting story is great, but an exciting and thought-provoking story is even better.

What do you think gives a book value? Which type of book do you prefer to read? Please share your thoughts in the comments.


Do Novels Need a Theme or Message to Have Value? — 1 Comment

  1. Pingback: Entertainment as King, Believability as Servant | Zachary Totah

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *